There is a huge difference, the material cuts faster lasts longer. When we started to do Valplast eons ago was when I first tried synthetic. It was like night and day different on this material. When we took the Valplast training they recommended "course" pumice to polish, it was like beach sand, I hated it and went back to my regular pumice till I read something about the use of the synthetic on Valplast. I can't imagine not using it now. Get a box I think you will see a difference as well.