You can sandblast them, clean them in acid, run over them with a dump truck. They don't damage.
You probably just had some left over emax or investment on the plunger so it didn't press straight and crooked, pushing the side of your ring into a crack.
The Atox plungers are great. But not if your pressing .7+ grams of wax with one ingot. If your cutting it close I would use a disposable. Cause the CTE of the atox is different and the button cracks. If you don't have much of a button, the crack can easily spider down a spru and into the restoration.
Just sandblast them and run your fingers on them to make sure their clean and nothings left.