If your casts are damp they won't stick to the Blu Tack, which is what I use. They have to be pretty much totally dry from model trimming or else I have to super glue them to the tack. It wastes just the top layer of tack. When they're damp, I've tried roughening the surface to get them to stick but to no avail without super gluing them.
For me, when they're dry, I've found that I have mound it up a bit and push and twist down back and forth, (or twist and shout
) the stone models into the tack, to get it to stick better. Make sure you're using enough. I have 2 plates with a good amount on them for casts, and 2 with little mounds for dies.