Just remade one last week due to breaking the top of the abutment off. It wan't quite as extreme as your photo, but along the same line, overextending to fill in the space.
The Dr placed the implant. This is the 2nd one he has placed like this. The 1st one I "refused" to close the space. It ended up in being for a engineer, who understood my concerns of fulcrum and occlusal forces, and was ok with it. That case is still doing well.
On this remake, he said to charge him full price, and to make it narrower (a canoe) and light occlusion, and if this one fails, we will do the 3rd one and not close the space, like we did the other patient. He did say I would be charging him full price, if it was needed. At least he is realistic in that regard, as far as my time and labor. Poor patient, though. Possibly 3 times for 1 implant